What to Do If A Car Accident is Your Fault

This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by Founding Partner, Terry Crouppen who has more than 40 years of legal experience as a personal injury attorney. Our last modified date shows when this page was last reviewed.

Brown & Crouppen

Car accidents are traumatic events, even for the at-fault driver. In some situations, the fault is apparent: a driver is distracted by their phone and does not see the brake lights ahead, causing a rear-end collision. Other times, there may be some shared fault. However, if you believe you are the at-fault party, honesty is still the best policy. Here is a breakdown of the steps you will want to take if you are the at-fault driver.

Contact your auto insurance company immediatelyYour auto insurance company will want to know about any potential claims as soon as possible to collect evidence. If you are upfront with what happened, it will make it easier for the insurance company to accept liability and get any injury or property damage claims made against you resolved. If you withhold information or refuse to take responsibility for the accident, the insurance company may deny the claim and force the injured party to seek a car accident lawyer for filing a lawsuit.


Ask for how much the other driver’s property damage settled. Ask how badly hurt the other parties were injured. Ask how much insurance coverage you must cover the case. Ask what offers are made and whether the injured party ever agreed to settle the case within the policy limits. Your insurance company gets to decide what they are willing to offer, but you can ask them to settle the case for the policy limits.

Adjusters and defense attorneys love to tell you that the injured person and their attorney are being unreasonable. Still, they will not often tell you that they made a policy limit demand (meaning they agreed to settle the case for the policy limits). The insurance company refused to offer the limits, making it more likely that you will be dragged through litigation. If the injured party files a lawsuit and gets a verdict that is more than your policy limits, you must pay that! However, if you ask questions and ask the insurance company to settle the case within limits early on, you may be able to claim bad faith against your insurance company later.


The defense attorney is supposed to represent you, but the adjuster gets to make the financial (and often strategic) decisions on your case. This is a conflict of interest. Ask the defense attorney to sit down with you and ask that they forward all correspondence from the injured party and their attorney. If they refuse, then you know that they are working for your best interest. Though there is an initial cost to it, getting independent counsel may help save you from an expensive verdict in the long run.


The best cure is prevention. Before you get into an accident, look at what kind of insurance you have, your policy limits, and ask what happens if you are in an accident. Likely you will be talking to an insurance agent at that point who will tell you that everything will be taken care of “no problem,” but be wary of insurance that seems too good (and too cheap) to be true. There is a reason they are cheap – they do not responsibly pay out their claims.


Text with a live representative
Text “GETBC” to 314-222-2222
Standard rates apply