October 14, 2026

$350,000 Settlement for Finger Amputation Caused by Defective Apartment Window in St. Louis

Brown & Crouppen Secures $350,000 in St. Louis Apartment Complex Injury Case

Brown & Crouppen secured a $350,000 settlement in a St. Louis premises liability case involving a defective, 100-pound apartment window that fell onto a client’s hand, causing a partial finger amputation.

Attorney Jenifer Snow represented the injured client in a case involving a malfunctioning window balance system, disputed liability, and serious injuries. The case settled on October 14, 2026, following litigation in St. Louis City, for approximately 8.8 times the defendant’s initial pre-suit settlement offer of $39,605.08.

Defective 100-Pound Apartment Window Causes Serious Hand Injury

The client suffered a partial finger amputation when a heavy apartment window suddenly fell, trapping her hand and fingers.

The approximately 100-pound window lacked a functioning balance system, the mechanical component designed to counterbalance a window’s weight and allow it to remain safely open. Without a working balance system, the window could drop unexpectedly, creating a serious safety hazard.

Because the window’s balance system was not functioning properly, apartment maintenance staff had placed cans of food beneath the approximately 100-pound window to keep it open. With the apartment becoming excessively hot while the client was cooking due to a malfunctioning HVAC system, the window needed to remain open for ventilation. When the client heard the cans beginning to crush under the window’s weight, she attempted to reposition them. The window then collapsed onto her hand, causing the partial amputation.

The incident raised serious questions about the apartment complex’s maintenance practices, including its failure to properly maintain critical building systems and address the dangerous property conditions that ultimately contributed to the client’s injury.

Disputed Liability Complicates St. Louis Premises Liability Claim

Determining responsibility for the defective apartment window was a central challenge in the case.

The parties disputed who instructed apartment maintenance personnel to place canned food beneath the window as a temporary support. These conflicting accounts complicated the liability assessment and raised questions about responsibility for the hazardous condition.

Despite these challenges, Brown & Crouppen pursued the client’s claim through litigation, examining the defective window balance system, maintenance circumstances, and events leading to the injury.

Litigation Results in $350,000 Settlement After Initial $39,605 Offer

Before litigation, the defendant offered $39,605.08 to resolve the client’s injury claim. Rather than accepting the initial offer, Brown & Crouppen attorney Jenifer Snow pursued litigation in St. Louis City, developing the evidentiary record and addressing the disputed liability issues.

The case ultimately resolved for $350,000, approximately 8.8 times the original pre-suit offer.

The outcome illustrates how investigating dangerous property conditions and pursuing litigation can contribute to the resolution of complex premises liability claims, particularly when serious injuries and disputed liability are involved.

When Can an Apartment Complex Be Liable for a Defective Window Injury?

Apartment owners and property managers may be held legally responsible when unsafe property conditions cause injuries and the requirements for premises liability are established under Missouri law.

Defective windows, malfunctioning balance systems, inadequate property maintenance, and unsafe temporary repairs can create dangerous conditions for apartment residents and visitors.

Determining liability may involve reviewing maintenance records, prior complaints, the condition of the window, and whether responsible parties knew or should have known about the dangerous condition.

Victims who suffer serious injuries, including crushed fingers, hand injuries, or amputations, may be entitled to pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other recoverable damages.

Injured Due to Unsafe Apartment Conditions in St. Louis? Contact Brown & Crouppen

If you or a loved one suffered an injury because of a defective window, unsafe apartment conditions, or negligent property maintenance, Brown & Crouppen can help you understand your legal options.

Our St. Louis personal injury attorneys represent individuals injured by dangerous property conditions throughout Missouri, including apartment complex accidents and other premises liability incidents.

Contact Brown & Crouppen today for a free consultation to discuss your injury and learn whether you may have grounds for a premises liability claim.

You can also explore additional Brown & Crouppen case results to learn more about the firm’s experience representing injured clients.

white woman on phone after motorcycle accident
Were you injured in an accident?
Call Brown & Crouppen at

Related Articles

person-holding-ankle-after-slip-and-fall-accident

Can I Sue for a Slip and Fall Accident?

Yes, you can sue for a slip and fall accident if someone else’s negligence caused it. Slip and fall injuries can happen anywhere, from grocery store aisles to icy sidewalks, and often lead to costly medical bills, lost wages, and long-term recovery challenges.

Read More...

SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION